2021/1675/EOUT Application for Outline Planning Permission for the erection of up to 1,700 dwellings (Use Class C3), two care homes (Use Class C3), 6.7 hectares of employment land (Use Classes E, B2 and B8), a mixed use local centre for primary school (Use Class F1), cafes/restaurant and convenience store (Use Class E) and other supporting social and physical infrastructure (Use Classes F1, F2 and E), provision of greenspace and other supporting ancillary works. All matters (Access (within the site), Layout, Scale, Appearance, Landscaping) reserved except for four new vehicular site access points from the existing highway. (Revisions & further information in respect of the Environmental Statement submitted 21.02.24).
Land Value Alliances the land promoters behind SGC have put the site up for sale as three lots, but they would sell to one developer if they came forward. One of our concerns is having to deal with multiple developers in the next and future stages of the planning process. Hopefully it will go to one lead developer that will help with the governance of the development.
2nd April 2026 Planning Inquiry Decision – Approved.
The Planning inspector and the Secretary of State approved the application pretty much in full.
Selwood Parish Council made representations at the Selwood Garden Community planning inquiry on highways and the governance of the development.
On highways All our suggestions were rejected. No crawler lane up the Ski Slope (the steepest slope in the area), no footbridge over the bypass to Tytherington and no improvements to the A361/A362 junction on the bypass. The entrance to the new Blatchbridge Industrial Estate will be shoved in between two homes and the B3092 road priority altered to favour the industrial estate. Even the bus route down narrow Little Keyford Lane was agreed. Somerset Council and Land Value Alliances (LVA) argued the 4,000 extra cars and the extra trucks this will add to our roads won’t need any major changes to our road network. The town will just get a few changes to The Butts and another contribution to the Gorehedge junction. National Highways were less convinced and got a £4.2m contribution to improve the A36 at White Row and Beckington. We hope Somerset Council and Land Value Alliances (LVA) got their numbers right, time will tell.
On governance we made the point that the LVA are a land promoter, who will now sell the land on, in phases, to various developers. This is by far the largest development by LVA to date their average site is for 80 houses and their largest so far is for 252 houses. Each developer then has the ability to change the vision that LVA has promised at the next stage in the planning process, Remaining Matters. We suggested that a lead developer be appointed to the whole site to ensure the vision promised has more chance of being delivered. That option was also suggested by LVA at the inquiry but has not been insisted upon by the inspector.
1,700 houses, a nature park, primary school, two care homes, some local shops, commercial and industrial units. It will be accessed by two roundabouts on the A361 and the B3090.
August 2025 The Planning Inquiry
Cllrs Jim Dowling (Chairman) and Richard Hammons attended the Planning Inquiry for Selwood Parish Council. This was held from the 5th – 7th August in Somerset Council’s offices in Shepton Mallet. This was followed by a very thorough site visit on the 12th August, which included a tour of the town showing how the SGC site would link into the town centre, and the remoteness of the SGC site from middle/upper schools, leisure and medical centres. Interestingly the Inspector Stephen Normington stayed in Trowbridge for the inqury period so he travelled the Frome Bypass every day to get to know the area. The Somerset Cllrs, Helen Kay, Mick Dunk, Barry Clarke and Shane Collins spoke at the inquiry, Cllr Martin Dimery was absent on holiday. Somerset Council chose to be neutral did not take a position, Frome Town Council did not object and thus did not speak during the inquiry. LVA were represented by a King’s Council Paul Tucker and he was instrumental in organising a robust defence and justification of their plans and the benefits that the development could bring to the town; additional housing, helping close the big gap in housing supply within Somerset Council’s area, additional employment areas, riverside park and by using locally based advisors demonstrated local knowledge. The objectors highlighted the additional improvements to infrastructure needed and the risks to the governance of this strategic development (LVA has no experience of managing a development of this size being developed by several builders over 16 years , their average site is about 80 dwellings not 1,700). Transport for New Homes and Stop SGC highlighted the increased use of the Frome bypass, the likely car dependence of the development with the implications that would mean for roads in Frome and the surrounding area and that the transport issues caused by the development make it unsustainable. The chamber of commerce want the employment zone to bring in a large keystone employer who can bring other supporting businesses into the area and be a source of well paid high skilled jobs. Friends of the River Frome focused on the risk of more sewage seeping into the local rivers and the flood risks of building in an area of steep hills and largely clay soils. Frome Civic Society pointed out the risks and items that are overlooked when such a large development is proposed outside of the Local Plan process and the dangers that entails such as the lack of consultation with BANES and Wiltshire Council’s on the cumulative impact of this development on top of the significant developments in Trowbridge, Westbury and Warminster. CPRE raised the issue of how the development might ruin the landscape character and setting of the town, however it was noted that Somerset Council has assessed the SGC site as being of low landscape character value. Interestingly land from the Marston Road to Edmunds Park and to the north of the town around Spring Gardens, Oldford, Beckington, Rode, Farleigh Hungerford and Norton St. Philip were similarly described as having low landscape character value. Berkley, East and West Woodlands and the escarpment to the west of Marston Lane has high or very high landscape character value The list of objectors included Selwood Parish Council, the four Somerset cllrs already mentioned, CPRE Somerset, Friends of the River Frome, Frome Civic Society, Transport for New Homes, Stop SGC, Frome & District Chamber of Commerce and several individuals. Interestingly because LVA (SGC) had no official opposition the inspector allowed the people present to cross examine the speakers. The topics where the evidence was discussed in detail were:
- Landscape and Visual Impact
- Highways and Transportation
- Planning
At the end of the inquiry the inspector held a roundtable meeting to discuss the potential conditions and S106 agreements that would be needed if the application is approved. LVA (SGC), Selwood Parish Council, Frome Town Council, Somerset Councils and Cllrs Helen Kay and Mick Dunk participated in these discussions.
Inspector Normington intends to visit the area again in September when more normal traffic levels will exist. He will then write his report which then does up to the Secretary of State for Housing, Communities and Local Government currently the Rt Hon Angela Rayner MP. we can expect a decision in October or November 2025.
July 2025
The Planning Inquiry hearing begins on the 5th August in the Somerset Council offices, Cannards Grave Road, Shepton Mallet. Requests to move it to Frome so more people could attend were made by our Anna Sabine our MP, Parish and Somerset councillors were refused. It is due to last four days. There will be a site inspection tour on the 12th August.
15 April 2025
The planning inquiry will be heard in a public hearing starting on the 29th July 2025 at a location in Frome. The planning inquiry is a Call in and as such is an inquisitorial proceeding to investigate and consider the pro’s and con’s of the development and make a decision to approve or reject the application. If they approve they may seek to add conditions to the approval. Somerset Council would be the party holding these Section 106 conditions and commitments from Land Value Alliances. We have submitted objections and concerns on highways and on the governance of the development, we will represent the parish council’s views at the inquiry as an “interested party”. All the Inquiry documents should be posted on Somerset’s planning portal, click on the planning reference number at the top of this page. The Planning inquiry reference is APP/E3335/V/25/3360037
During a special meeting of the Planning Committee on the 28th March 2025 it was decided after much discussion that Somerset Council will be neutral and not offer any opinion on the application. This was justified by on costs grounds and that as the decision has been taken out of Somerset Councils hands “why should they have an opinion”. Frome Town Council have received some assurances from the land promoter LVA and they have decided to support the application. This means that there is unlikely to be any legally represented opposition party in the inquiry. It will be reliant on the Inspector to pull all the evidence together. LVA the land promoter will be representing themselves with a barrister who will, no doubt, cross examine anyone putting up objections or concerns.
3 February 2025
On the eve of the Planning Committee meeting to again debate this application the Secretary of State for the Department of Housing, Communities and Local Government has decided to “call in” the application to the Planning Inspectorate to determine the application. It is a very large speculative application which is outside of the Local Plan and has not had the rigorous detailed investigations and cross boundary consultations that happen when sites are earmarked for development within the Local Plan. It appears that the call in was due to a request from Transport for New Homes who raised several concerns about the application and the way it was being handled. It’s unusual for a such a large and strategic development outside of the Local Plan to be decided without the rigor that would usually be applied to such developments, including liaising with neighbouring authorities who would be impacted by the build. However the Secretary of State is very keen to hit her housing targets. There will now be a call for detailed evidence and then a full planning inquiry. Please view the planning portal on the link above for the new and more detailed objections and briefing papers submitted in recent weeks. The Planning officers reports can be found on the Planning Committee East website (just click the link) for the dates this was discussed or scheduled i.e. 3rd December 2024 and 4th February 2025.
An extract of the call in letter is below:
On the information so far available to the Secretary of State, the matters which she particularly wishes to be informed about for the purposes of her consideration of the application are:
a) The extent to which the proposed development is consistent with Government policies for Delivering a sufficient supply of homes in the NPPF (NPPF Chapter 5);
b) The extent to which the proposed development is consistent with Government policies for Building a strong, competitive economy in the NPPF (Chapter No.6);
c) The extent to which the proposed development is consistent with Government policies for Promoting sustainable transport in the NPPF (Chapter No.9);
d) The extent to which the proposed development is consistent with Government policies for Conserving and enhancing the natural environment in the NPPF (Chapter No.15);
e) The extent to which the proposed development is consistent with the development plan for the area; and
f) any other matters the Inspector considers relevant.
MINISTRY_OF_HOUSING__COMMUNITIES___LOCAL_GOVERNMENT-1414164
3 December 2024 This evening after over four hours of presentations and deliberations Planning Committee East narrowly decided to be “minded to refuse the application”. Another vote will then be taken to approve the reasons for refusal. LVA the promoters are then very likely to appeal this to the Planning Inspector, an act that must be done within 13 weeks for the refusal. If they appeal the next stage will be public hearings sometime in 2025. Hopefully at least then we will get more than three minutes to make our points. A recording of meeting will be online soon, we’ll post a link here. The officers of Somerset Council recommended approval and rebutted pretty much every point made by the objectors, some of the Councillors were not persuaded by their arguments. The meeting was addressed by the following objectors:
- Ken McCall
- CPRE Somerset
- Stop SGC
- Friends of the River Frome
- Frome Civic Society
- Frome Town Council
- Selwood Parish Council – 2 Speakers (covering highways and sewage/flooding)
- Cllr Mick Dunk
- Cllr Shane Collins
The only people speaking in favour were all promoter linked:
- Land Value Alliances – the promoter
- Grassroots – promotors agent
- Neil Brandt Consulting – promoters transport consultant
The minded to refuse decision was based on the Committee detailing the reasons for refusal and two months has been allocated to preparing these reasons and evidencing them. The reasons will be under the following headings:
- Not within the local plan – not an identified development site
- Environmental concerns
- Landscape loss
- Damage to the character and setting of the town
- No delivery vehicle/governance
- Unsustainable flood and foul water handing
- Loss of existing residents amenity
- Transport infrastructure insufficient
- Disproportional level of growth for Frome
26 November 2024 This has been put on the agenda for the Planning Committee East to consider on the 3rd December 2024 at 2pm at Somerset Council’s offices in Shepton Mallet it is being recommended for approval and all of the objections raised have been dismissed by the Planning officer’s report (click on this link for the report). National Highways have withdrawn their holding recommendation to allow the application to be determined. Please attend if you can, public feeling can influence decisions as we saw recently with the Saxonvale. Alternatively lobby your Somerset Councillor, four of them sit on this planning committee and the others will be speaking at the meeting.
28 August 2024 National Highways have again requested another three months to consider. This defers any planning committee decision until 28 November 2024, so the the December committee meeting at the earliest. The A36 trunk road that they are responsible for is impacted by the significant developments built or building in Frome, Westbury, Warminster and Trowbridge. Due to the weight restriction on Cleveland Bridge, Bath (18 tonnes) it is likely that the National Highways will reclassify the A350 from Beckington to the M4 as a trunk road, this is effectively the route that most HGV’s take today.
20 June 2024 Planning Committee East visited the site with the Planning Officer in mid-June, which tends to mean that this will come to Planning Committee in the near future. On the 30th May the Highways Agency have asked the Council not to approve any planning consent for another 3 months, they are considering the impact the development will have on the A36 trunk road. The Highways Agency request for deferment postpones any approval until the 30th August, but this is the latest in a series of deferment requests, previously it has been postponed for 6 months at a time.
Selwood Garden Community 2021_1675_EOUT Highways Considerations and Recommendations
Selwood Parish Council Letter of Objection. April 2024
Frome Town Council update 17th April 2024
Frome Town Council Update 24th November 2023
